fbpx

TherapySpark

Research Shows Eccentric Exercise – Not Needling, Surgery, Splints – Best for Tendinopathy

new-tendinopathy-research-eccentric-exercise-better-than-surgery-needling-interventions

It is certain that the year 2020 will be forever remembered for countless reasons.  Every level of medical care has been impacted by COVID-19 and some may have changed for more than just the short term.  Many clinics have had to try new methods of therapy.  Telehealth, home health, decreased frequency and length of visits, and of course PPE have all become somewhat commonplace today.

One thing that WILL NOT change moving forward is the need for evidence-based solutions to clinical problems.  People will continue to need expert clinicians to help facilitate a return to function and health. During this time, we must make the most productive use of our time and our patients’ time.  One particular way we can achieve effective and strong outcomes is with eccentric exercise.

Literature review of tendinopathy treatments in multiple joints

In May of 2020, researchers at the University of Nebraska and Temple University produced a study looking at clinical management of tendinopathy1.  This systemic review of systemic reviews aimed to “determine the ability of therapeutic interventions to improve pain and dysfunction in patients with tendinopathy regardless of type or location.”  The review only included randomized control trials looking at treatments for tendinopathy.

Twenty-five reviews met the authors’ criteria, looking at tendinopathies at various areas in the body. Patients reported their experience using pain scales, which determined how effectively various treatments worked. The study looked at eccentric exercise, surgery, dry needling, shockwave therapy, splints, Platelet Rich Plasma Therapy, laser therapy, ultrasound, iontophoresis, ultrasound guided lavage and corticosteroids for treating the various tendinopathies.

            Eccentric exercises were the most common and consistently effective treatment for tendinopathy across systematic reviews. When treating tendinopathy regardless of location, eccentric exercises were the best treatment option to improve tendinopathy-related pain and improve self-reported function. – Irby, et al 2020

Eccentric exercise is the most effective treatment for all tendinopathies

The data and patient reports showed that each treatment intervention provided some level of improvement.  But exercise was the most consistently effective option. More specifically, eccentric exercise was the single most effective treatment for all joints in the study1.

In fact, patients with Achilles tendinopathy showed pain decreases of as much as 29-94% when the lower leg was loaded with high eccentric force1. This systemic review produced a conclusion on the pathology of tendinopathies as a whole vs each joint and individual pathology.

Eccentrics in your evidence-based practice

So, what does this mean?  Well, it means that PTs, OTs, and ATCs can use this evidence-based concept in more cases with more confidence.  At times, some may hesitate to prescribe eccentric exercise. This hesitation comes from the slight risk of eliciting Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness (DOMS) or from perceived weakness of the client.  However, in many cases, the eccentric deficit could be an integral part of the underlying problem. Therefore, we should address it directly with eccentric loading.

Additional resources on eccentric exercise in rehab

Unless you’re new to TherapySpark, you’re probably familiar with our encouragement of eccentric exercise for rehab, injury prevention, and athletic conditioning. Check out these other resources about eccentrics:

Eccentric exercise works.  Don’t be afraid to use it with clients of all sorts of pathologies.  It continues to show efficacy in today’s rehabilitation and injury prevention domains.

Harness the power of eccentrics with the Eccentron

Whether you work with elderly patients at risk for falls, or high-powered athletes, the Eccentron delivers all the benefits of eccentric exercise. With eccentric loading, the body can resist up to 40% more weight than with concentric loading. And, it requires 80% less oxygen because the muscles are resisting rather than pushing.

Eccentron users have seen incredible outcomes with continued use, both in athletic training and rehabilitation. For example, the Houston Rockets consider it an essential part of their strengthening and conditioning – so much that the Eccentron was one of the few pieces of training equipment that they brought to the NBA Bubble. In the rehabilitation side, the Eccentron has proven itself as a safe intervention for knee osteoarthritis, sarcopenia prevention, fall prevention, rebuilding strength and stability in frail patients, and ACL recovery.

Emphasizing treatment that is both efficient and effective

In this unique time, we all have had to re-evaluate our methods in which we provide care.  For many, that has meant more telehealth sessions.  For others, it has meant a decrease in patient visits and even clinic staff size to minimize person to person interactions.  As we look to the future, there will be even further emphasis on producing quick and effective results in the services that we provide.

Objective and evidence-based care that also limit’s the risk of contact will likely continue long past 2020.  Working with objective technology that encourages added eccentric contractions can help keep you productive and highly effective at achieving positive patient outcomes!

 

Jeffrey Johnson, MA, ATC
Clinical Specialist
BTE

 

Reference

  1. Irby A, Gutierrez, J, Chamberlin C, Thomas S, Rosen A. 2020. Clinical management of tendinopathy: A systemic review of systemic reviews evaluating the effectiveness of tendinopathy treatments.  Scand J Med Sci Sports. 00:1–17.